Warning: AI May Cause Creativity Side Effects

Generative AI isn’t just changing how we create — it’s reshaping what AI creativity means.

Whether you’re a marketer, writer, designer, or content creator, the rise of AI tools like ChatGPT, Midjourney, and Claude is pushing us to rethink workflows, storytelling, and what sets human creativity apart.

7 ways AI impacts creativity

Educator and writer John Spencer brilliantly outlined seven ways generative AI impacts creativity. Below, I’ve broken down his ideas and added my take on why they matter to creative professionals.

1. Centaur vs. Cyborg: Choosing Your Workflow Style

What it means:

• Centaur: You work separately from AI — for example, using it to brainstorm, then writing the final piece yourself.
• Cyborg: You work side-by-side with AI throughout the creative process.

Why it matters:
Knowing how you want to collaborate with AI shapes everything from tone to productivity. Marketers who master this choice can optimize their time and produce better results, without losing their unique voice. Use AI creativity to think differently.

2. Vintage Innovation: Old-School Meets New Tech

What it means:
AI sparks a return to retro aesthetics and analog styles — but with a modern remix.

Why it matters:
Nostalgia sells. Combining vintage design, tone, or formats with AI-powered speed gives marketers a powerful formula for emotionally resonant, scroll-stopping campaigns. Think human-centered but tech-infused.

3. Fast Draft, Slow Craft: Speed + Soul

What it means:
Use AI to whip up a first draft fast, then take your time refining the final product.

Why it matters:
Writers can now invest more effort in polishing and elevating their message while cutting time spent wrestling with the blank page. The first 80% gets easier, but the last 20% is your secret sauce.

4. Product vs. Process: It’s How You Make It

What it means:
AI shifts focus from the final deliverable to the creative journey, full of rapid iterations and pivots.

Why it matters:
This lets content creators do more A/B testing, live iteration, and creative flexibility. You can now treat content like software: versioned, tested, and improved continuously.

5. Constraint-Driven Creativity: Creativity Loves Boundaries

What it means:
AI limitations — or creative prompts — can spark surprising, novel ideas.

Why it matters:
Constraints like “write this in 50 words” or “explain this like a pirate” push creators to think differently. AI becomes a sandbox for playful brand storytelling and fresh campaign ideas. Inject context and empathy.

6. Messy Middle: AI as Your Mid-Project Lifeline

What it means:
The “middle” of a project — where you’re unsure or stuck — is where AI is most helpful.

Why it matters:
AI can help unblock, restructure, or remix content in the middle phase, keeping momentum alive. It’s like having a creative coach who never runs out of suggestions. Let iteration drive your creativity.

7. Democratic Creativity: The Playing Field Just Got Crowded

What it means:
AI makes creativity accessible to more people — no elite skills required.

Why it matters:
Anyone can generate content now. Standing out depends less on access to tools and more on brand clarity, original insight, and taste. The bar is higher — not in production, but in resonance. Are you derivative or distinctive?

My Take: 3 AI Creativity Shifts to Watch

1. AI Doesn’t Replace Taste — It Amplifies It

AI can generate content, but only humans know what great feels like. Your creative edge will come from refining taste, making smart edits, and knowing what resonates. In the end, AI is your megaphone, not your message.

2. Brand Voice Needs Stronger Guardrails

With faster content output comes the risk of going off-brand. Savvy marketers will build prompt libraries, style guides, and editorial guardrails to ensure consistency. AI is your intern, but you must still be the creative director.

3. From One Big Idea to 100 Small Experiments

Instead of chasing a single winning campaign idea, creators can test dozens of micro-ideas. AI makes iteration cheap and winners easier to find. Creative success will increasingly be a numbers game + taste game.

Final Thought

Generative AI is not the enemy of creativity — it’s the catalyst. It won’t do your job for you, but it will change how you do it. For marketers and creators who embrace the shifts, this isn’t the end of originality — it’s the beginning of a bright new chapter.

By Jeff Domansky, Managing Editor

Recent AI Marketer Blog posts:

AI Prompts for Short Answers Lead to More Hallucinations — How to Avoid Them